-
Create solutions that bring maximum success and value under our expert product management guidanceEnsure your product idea viability and get the right market and development strategies to succeedGet a product that directly addresses your customer needs and matches the goals of your businessBring your customers an exceptional user experience and make your product stand out with our designGet designs that amplify your product features with clear, intuitive, and sales-boosting user experienceNurture customer loyalty, boost sales, and expand your market presence with a stand-out mobile appGet higher customer satisfaction, more conversions, and better competitiveness with our UX auditCreate a custom software solution to unlimit your business capabilitiesStart and grow your startup fast or effectively renovate your existing solution with our RoR expertsExtend your product line quicker and cheaper by creating a secure, reliable, and flexible API solutionGet expert technical assistance in building real-time React-based web applications and SPAsBuild a high-performing web application with our Vue.js development company.Create robust native or cross-platform mobile apps for your business with our expert assistanceGet native-like mobile apps for both Android and iOS using the best cross-platform technologiesCreate native iOS, iPadOS, and tvOS applications to cover any of the desired Apple user segmentsCreate 99.9% crash-free native Android applications for any available device and screen typesEnsure the top quality and bug-free performance of your products by fixing all issues at early stagesConsult our experts to build an efficient quality assurance strategy for your productEnable full lifecycle software testing services to detect and fix all product issues at the earliest stageReveal all non-typical performance, security, and usability issues with our manual QA servicesBoost your overall software development velocity with our robust automation testing solutionEnsure the usability, security, performance, compliance, and compatibility of your web appsProvide your customers with mobile apps free from any usability, security, and performance issuesUse our functional testing services to ensure every product feature works as expected in all scenarios.Ensure a seamless user experience across all digital environments with our compatibility testing servicesMake technologies work for your business growth and choose the right ones to achieve specific goalsImprove app performance, setup continuous delivery, cut infrastructure costs with our DevOps servicesKeep your product stably up, running and get timely feature upgrades with our maintenance servicesClean your software from code issues and uncover possible improvements to boost its performanceEnsure security of your healthcare products and achieve HIPAA compliance with our expert assistance
-
Multi-Vendor Marketplace Online Store Custom Marketplace Telemedicine Software Chat App Custom Booking System Video Conferencing For Enterprise For StartupsBuild a custom multi-vendor marketplace fast and cost-efficiently using our MarketAge solutionLaunch a custom B2B marketplace for any type of products with MarketAgeLaunch a unique, custom-functional B2C marketplace at minimum effort with MarketAge white-lable productReduce costs to build an easy-to-use and reliable C2C marketplace using our MarketAge solutionCreate an online store with unique design and features at minimal cost using our MarketAge solutionGet a unique, scalable, and cost-effective online marketplace with minimum time to marketGet a cost-efficient, HIPAA-compliant telemedicine solution tailored to your facility's requirementsGet a customizable chat solution to connect users across multiple apps and platformsImprove your business operations and expand to new markets with our appointment booking solutionAdjust our video conferencing solution for your business needsScale, automate, and improve business processes in your enterprise with our custom software solutionsTurn your startup ideas into viable, value-driven, and commercially successful software solutions
-
Streamline and scale your e-commerce business with a custom platform tailored to your product segmentsAutomate, scale, secure your financial business or launch innovative Fintech products with our helpCut paperwork, lower operating costs, and expand yout market with a custom e-learning platformUpgrade your workflow, enter e-health market, and increase marketability with the right custom software
-
Discover our software engineering culture, what principles we follow to make our clients succeedOur BA office helps clients choose the right development strategy and get maximum value at minimum riskFind out how we manage development risks, ensure on-time delivery, and prevent budget overrunsWe create clear, intuitive, and functional designs to solve specific business problems of our clientsSee what techniques and principles we follow to engineer top-tier software products at RubyGarageSee how our QA office ensures zero usability and functional issues in every product we deliver to clientsDiscover more of RubyGarage’s culture, values, and strengthsDevelop your product in a clear workflow aimed to save your time and budget and boost the qualityJoin our team to build a successful career in software development. See open positions at RubyGarage
- Case Studies
- Blog
Arguments For and Against Code Refactoring
Code refactoring is an inevitable part of any project’s life cycle. As a project develops, its code becomes outdated. So it’s not a question of whether you should or shouldn’t refactor (the answer is always yes, you should). The question is when it’s time to refactor. In this article, we help you figure that out.
When refactoring is a must
Code refactoring is the process of restructuring code to improve its readability and reduce its complexity without making any changes to its external behavior.
Let’s consider the cases when to refactor your code.
#1 You make significant upgrades or are faced with legacy code
The development of a project shouldn’t stop when it’s launched. With more users, code gets slower and new bugs appear, requiring fixes. Besides, over time, you may want to add new functionality, use a new technology, or replace outdated libraries.
But what should you do if your project’s codebase is bulky? What if you have to deal with legacy code? The answer is that you should refactor it. Follow the advice below to get the best results when refactoring legacy code:
- Don’t start refactoring right away. When you inherit legacy code, you or your team may (and most likely will) think the code is ugly. However, if it does the job, it’s not that bad. Don’t dive into refactoring and trying to fix all the weaknesses until you get acquainted with the code. There’s a chance it has dependencies you’re unaware of.
- Start small. Don’t refactor the whole codebase at once. It will take too long and your team will get stuck in refactoring process without a chance to do any other work. It’s better to plan small changes in every sprint. This will allow your team to improve the code and develop it at the same time.
- Follow the Red-Green-Refactor principle when adding new functionality. Agile software development methodology calls for adding new functionality using the Red-Green-Refactor principle. Red means create tests, Green means write code to pass those tests. After red and green phases, developers can refactor the code, making it laconic and clean.
Always leave the code behind in a better state than you found it.
#2 There are lots of bugs
Fixing bugs without refactoring can lead to even more bugs, plus hours of tedious work.
Fixing one or a few bugs in your codebase may not require refactoring at all. However, a codebase with a lot of bugs (legacy code, for instance) can be what’s called spaghetti code. You fix one thing and another crashes.
Make sure the code you’re going to debug doesn’t have hidden dependencies or repetitions and is easy to read. If it does and/or it’s hard to read, refactor it and then debug.
#3 You need to make code robust to changes
It’s definitely time to refactor your codebase when you add new features and bugs appear in parts that weren’t changed and functioned perfectly before. It means your code is flaky.
To avoid this situation and create a codebase that’s resilient to changes, developers should follow principles of test-driven development and behavior-driven development as well as the SOLID and DRY principles.
If the codebase already exists, you can improve it with refactoring.
#4 There’s repetitive code
Repeated code is a common problem when several developers are working on different parts of the same project. Code gets repeated when developers simply don’t know that someone else has already written code they could reuse.
Such duplications lead to cases when a bug is fixed in one place but not in all other places. Fixing bugs in such code can become a nightmare, especially when a developer doesn’t understand which version is correct. Duplications also make code clumsy and slow.
The Don’t Repeat Yourself (DRY) principle, commonly used in Agile software development methodologies, aims at making all elements independent so a change to any single element of a system won’t require a change to other logically unrelated elements.
According to the DRY principle, code refactoring is the main cure for duplicated code. Refactoring helps to find repetitions and make code more laconic.
Martin Fowler describes the rule of three, which explains when to refactor, in his book Refactoring. He says that the first time developers do something, they should do it straightforwardly. The next time, if they do something similar, they can duplicate the existing piece of code. The third time, they should refactor.
#5 Code is hard to read
The main aim of refactoring is to improve the readability of code, making it more efficient and maintainable.
In many cases, it’s not even necessary to restructure code to do that. A developer can just rename a few functions or variables using more straightforward names and that will be enough to make the code more readable.
Any fool can write code that a computer can understand. Good programmers write code that humans can understand.
#6 There’s technical debt
Technical debt is often compared with monetary debt. When you don’t repay it, the interest compounds. Even if you don’t develop your software actively, the debt still gets bigger. Why? Because developers who worked on the project leave it, and those small sacrifices to code quality that they made to meet business deadlines or enter the market faster will show up in their full strength.
Technical debt causes consequences on different levels. Here are just some of them:
- New features take a long time to implement
- Broken deadlines and budgets
- Inaccurate estimates
- Vendor lock-in, when it’s almost impossible to change a software development company
There’s no way to avoid technical debt. Nevertheless, you can take some measures to minimize it. The Agile methodology calls for constant refactoring during development as the main weapon against technical debt. However, most managers and developers rarely get a chance to start a project from scratch. With an existing project, what they should do is schedule regular refactoring tasks for every sprint and reduce technical debt until the code is clean and can be easily read by a new team of developers.
Wrapping up
Refactoring is one of the most effective tools to keep your code quality high. That’s why you should make it a part of the software development routine and stop considering refactoring as an optional step to be taken from time to time.
The word ‘refactoring’ should never appear in a schedule. Refactoring is not a story or a backlog item. Refactoring is not a scheduled task. Refactoring is immediate and continuous. It’s like washing your hands in the bathroom. You always do it.
When not to refactor
Refactoring has to be an essential part of the development process. However, there are some cases when refactoring is a waste of time and money. Let’s find out when you should consider some other options apart from refactoring.
You don’t have enough code coverage
Code refactoring can cause more harm than good if you don’t have all the necessary tests in place.
When dealing with legacy code that doesn’t have proper test coverage, you can’t be sure the code you’re refactoring works correctly. If you can’t check how your changes influence the code, it’s better to postpone refactoring. Otherwise, you can easily mess something up.
The Agile methodology, which helps developers create high-quality software fast, also promotes test-driven development (TDD). This development approach teaches developers to write automation tests before the code itself and requires refactoring after each iteration. Using a test-driven development approach, you’ll have tests to run after each little step of the refactoring process.
It’s not clear where to move
When you have to deal with legacy code that doesn’t look very pretty, you understand that it needs to be improved. However, it’s not always obvious where to start and what to change to improve it.
Without a clear plan for refactoring, any attempts to change anything can lead to new bugs and complications. In such a case, it’s better to leave the code as is (if it does the job) and try to get to know it better.
After a while, when all the dependencies show up and you know the code inside and out, you’ll understand what parts of the code you need to refactor and how to do so successfully.
Module needs to be revamped completely
Sometimes, it’s much easier to rewrite a module in an app from scratch than to try to refactor and save it. Here are the cases when you can seriously consider this possibility:
- Your development team can barely understand the code
- Debugging is becoming more and more challenging
- More time is spent on fixing bugs than on implementing new features
- Any changes send ripple effects through the module
- Code is too messy and is difficult to maintain
- You know there’s a technology or framework that can dramatically reduce the amount of code in the module
If even one of the cases mentioned above describes the situation you’re in now, it’s probably time to retire the old code.
If you’ve decided to rewrite a module in your app, well-written tests can make your life significantly easier. With the proper tests, it’s relatively straightforward to create a new, more easily maintainable module. If you don’t have tests, start with writing a detailed specification and only then proceed to code.
You need to launch fast
If you want to enter the market as soon as possible (and there are a number of reasons why you may want to), you can ignore refactoring.
For instance, say you want to launch a minimum viable product (MVP) as a proof of concept or to validate a business idea and show it to your investors.
In such a case, bugs are irrelevant: they can be fixed later, or you can rebuild the MVP into a full-fledged system by applying TDD and Agile principles.
Another possible reason is a desire to get ahead of competitors and hit the market faster. Refactoring will only slow you down. You can sacrifice it to win the audience.
The bottom line
Code refactoring is an inherent part of the modern software development process. It should be considered a separate process only when you inherit an old codebase that’s difficult to read and maintain. In all other cases, refactoring should be part of the routine.
Don’t forget to subscribe to our blog, and feel free to ask us any questions below!
Subscribe via email and know it all first!